May 19th – Controversy Over a Turkish Celebration

May 19th is an official holiday in Turkey.  No, they don’t celebrate Malcolm X’s birthday!  The date is officially dubbed, “Youth and Sports Day.”

More importantly, May 19th is the day that  Mustafa Kemal (a.k.a. Atatürk, founding father of modern Turkey) landed at Samsun, which is regarded as the beginning of the Turkish War of Independence.

Turkish Flag Flying High Above Anitkabir

This year’s celebration became a big political mess.  The current government decided to change the way the celebrations had taken place for years.

Official ceremonies and military parades were replaced by civilian festivities this year, with people taking to the streets and public squares to mark the day. . . Until this year, militarism had been at the forefront of the May 19 celebrations. High school students used to parade in military formations in perfect precision in stadiums and perform athletic routines. Military troops also used to parade, with generals attending ceremonies in big cities alongside politicians. . . Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said May 19 had finally become a festival for the nation. “Tanks and troops no longer parade [to mark the day]. Now there are festivities. The youth are in the streets [for the celebrations]. Now May 19 is a real festival. Older celebrations used to recall those of iron curtain countries. May 19 is now a symbol of change and transformation.” The prime minister’s remarks came as he received youth representatives from 81 Turkish provinces and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (KKTC) at the prime minister’s office on Saturday morning.

The new style of celebrations came as part of the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government’s efforts towards normalization and the elimination of military influence from the education system. The Ministry of Education issued a circular early this year cancelling the May 19 celebrations in stadiums. Instead, the ministry said, the celebrations would be held in public squares to provide a chance for more widespread attendance.

Today’s Zaman 

The written word makes it sound like a good thing, and that it was a joyous day throughout the country.  It was not – not completely.

The local television news stations, while way too sensational for me, showed physical fights breaking out throughout the country.  It is in fact, the military who keeps the country “balanced.”  The military is the biggest supporter of Atatürk, protecting the laws of modern Turkey.  This seems a bit foreign to one who comes from a western society.  But in Turkey, the military is needed in other ways than a westerner would imagine.

Atatürk’s last message to the Turkish Army – at the entrance to the Hall of Honor at Anitkabir

While no government is perfect, the current party (AKP) leans far to the right and mixes religion with everything.  I have no problem with basic tenets of religion.  But I generally don’t believe it belongs in government.  I have to add though, I do also find that sometimes the so-called separation of church and state in this “secular” society goes too far – such as banning the head scarf from government properties.  This was likely law before the current party came into power.

This year, the Ministry of Education forbade people from celebrating in ways that they wanted.  Harmless ways.  The “civilian celebration” was completely prescribed by the government.  It just simply switched hands from military to government.  It was not a “people’s celebration” to the extent that the population was not permitted to celebrate as they wished.  For example, at a local university (owned by the government), students were forbidden from hanging a wreath on a statue of Atatürk.  Seriously?  A wreath!  What harm could that possibly cause?

Kemal Kılçdaroğlu, leader of the main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP), joined the celebrations in the Black Sea province of Samsun, where he criticized the government’s decision. “Since when do people need permission to remember [Mustafa Kemal] Atatürk?” said Kılıçdaroğlu. “We know to challenge every kind of oppression, no despot regime has survived.”

Hurriyet Daily News

On Saturday, my husband insisted on visiting Anıtkabira beautiful historic museum and the mausoleum of Atatürk.  It is one of the most visited tourist attractions in Turkey, set on a high hill in Ankara.

Anitkabir

I had been several times and did not at first see the importance of this visit.  But I went along.  When we arrived, I really didn’t want to be there.  Parking was closed except to a select few – the diplomats!  Surprisingly, we rather quickly found a spot on a crowded neighborhood street.

Then there was a long line to get through security.  Oddly, that also moved quickly.

The Line through Security

The walk up the hill was also enjoyable.  It was a gorgeous day with a light breeze.  The grounds of  Anıtkabir have always been well-maintained by the military with green grass and flowers everywhere.

Display of Turkish Pride along the Green Paths

Once inside the courtyard, I was stunned by the long queue of those waiting to pay their respects.  My husband wanted to get in the line.  I was annoyed.  We had just come from the pazar and there were bags of veggies in the hot car.  I told him to go – and promised to wait, but only for an hour.

Hundreds Wait in Line

I snuggled against a wall on the grand staircase and pulled out my camera.  Taking shots of this and that, my attention was grabbed by an impromptu group of mostly college-aged kids, who gathered in the middle of the stairs and began singing to commemorate Atatürk.  With no police around to enforce the AKP decision, the group was not interrupted during their personal celebration. (Sadly, I am not so familiar with my new camera.  I thought I had recorded for you but only got one sorry shot.)

Song to Ataturk

During this display, something touched my heart.  My husband being here meant something.  It was important to him.  I gazed across the courtyard and was amazed that I could pick him out in that long line.  He was still far away, but at least he had made the final turn of the long winding line.

What is important to him is important to me.  So I got up, climbed down the stairs and joined him in the line.  I was amazed by how orderly this line was. Except for a few who jumped in front, this was so untypical of Turks who usually push and shove to be first.

Atatürk will not be forgotten and his life will be celebrated by Turks in any way they choose, regardless of what the government says.  This day is not about religion – although some will choose to mix the two if they wish as I did, making the sign of the cross as I silently prayed for the people of Turkey.

Flowers for Ataturk

At Peace

I am very grateful to my husband for dragging me along and sharing this day in celebration with me.

Ataturk’s View of His City from the Hilltop

Before we left, we actually got to see the full pomp and circumstance of the changing of the guard.  Below is a short clip.

On Guard

I address the Turkish Army whose record of victory started at the down of the history of mankind and which has carried the light of civilization in its victorious progress.

I have no doubt that just as in the most critical and difficult times you saved the country from oppression, tragedy and enemy invasion, so today, in the fruitful era of the Republic equipped with all the modern weapons and means of military science you will do your duty with the same faith.

I and our great nation know that you are always prepared to carry out your duty defending the honor of our country and our civilization against danger, from inside our out.”

29th October 1938
President
Mustafa Kemal ATATÜRK

http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?f=80&t=120930

About these ads

14 thoughts on “May 19th – Controversy Over a Turkish Celebration

  1. personally I’d love to see and end to governments – since WW2 Italy had more of them than years and did fine until Burlesconi ‘established’ himself. Same in Belgium – no government for 18 months and weathered things better than most. A plague on all their houses!

  2. This is what blogs are for — personal insight, reflection, and a glue to events not possible in other formats. Thanks for documenting and sharing, Terry. I second the emotion you listed above and what Carol Fritz commented on — “what’s important to him is important to me”. Unity in this world is so valuable.

    • Hi Michael, Thanks for reading the blog. Happy to have you here and hope you will check back. I agree with your beliefs – unity is valuable. One world – one peace! BTW, Carol is an attorney I worked with in the States. Not sure, but she may also know your cousin. If you speak to your cousin, please tell her I said hello. Small world, isn’t it?

  3. Politics in Turkey is a complex and sometimes deadly business. Liberalism that puts a break on extremism in the West has shallow roots here. The political divide that runs like a fault line through the country is plain to see. I’m no fan of the AKP (how could I be?) but I found the festivities in Bodrum shorn of militaristic and nationalistic pretensions rather refreshing. But then Bodrum has always done things differently. And, what do I know? I’m just a bleeding heart liberal!

    • As you can tell, Jack, I’m not much of a political person at all, and also a bleeding heart liberal. Since I don’t speak the language well, I find it easy to avoid politics here for the most part. But from what I hear and understand, I completely agree with you. There doesn’t seem to be much crossing of political lines if any. I’ve gotten quite used to the military presence which is especially obvious in Ankara, where there are military in place to protect the homes of many diplomats and such. I’ve gotten used to seeing guns on a daily basis. But I will never get used to the way the tongues of journalists are tied. I met a photographer this weekend who has the same problem as the journalists. Tell it like it is, I say!

  4. Nice analysis. While I can say that I am a hundred percent anti-militarist, I find the bit that says “the military is needed in other ways than a westerner would imagine.” is is incredibly accurate.

  5. Hi Terry, thanks for this post and uplifting pictures: that sky is great. A visit to Anitkabir is very moving esp on a national day. What is happening with the military is v interesting: we think in a way their position is being regulated because before it was way out of line. But – there is always a but – Turkey needed a military like this and we all believed in it wholeheartedly, coups or no coups. I also liked what you said about yr husband and the effect that Anitkabir had on him. My husband wld be the same.
    Did you see your award on my blog???

    • Hi Claudia, Anitkabir can get boring in a way, after seeing it so many times, but it is still so majestic, sitting above the rest of us – and the gardens are beautiful. The fear of a coup is an interesting concept for many expats, but I guess it’s a reality for Turks, having been through one as recently as 1980.

      I got the award and will “handle” it soon! Thanks!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s